Dad’s Chocolate Chip Cookies

My father, who is recovering from a successful tussle with oral cancer, is one of the best bakers I know.

Although he is currently unable to eat (due to the side effects of the cancer therapy) he is constantly cooking and baking. Preparation is one half of the food ritual, after all– even if he can’t taste the final product, Dad still gets to be involved with the food. To make basic ingredients into something sublime. Interestingly, although generally pretty solid to begin with, many of his most-used recipes have become even better while he’s been unable to taste them. We’re very excited for his mouth to recover so he can enjoy his baked goods as much as we do.

This is my Dad’s recipe for chocolate chip cookies. It’s Tollhouse, perfected. Enjoy.


2 sticks of unsalted butter

1.5 cups brown sugar

2 eggs

2 tsp vanilla extract

3 cups flour (sometimes I use some whole wheat flour, but he uses 100% all-purpose)

1 tsp salt

1 tsp baking soda

chocolate chips, to suit (I generally throw them in by the fistful until I’m satisfied. Maybe 1-1/2 cups?)

chopped walnuts or pecans, optional, and to suit (Again with the fistfuls. Maybe 1 cup. Be sure you only include chunks of nut– the powdery, dusty remnants have a way of making you cough when you bite into them in the cookie, and in general mess up the cookie’s smooth texture.)

Step One: Put the brown sugar in a mixing bowl. (I love my Kitchenaid mixer, which was inherited from the grandmother and is significantly older than I am. You can do this with a hand mixer, but it’s going to take a while.) Melt the butter in the microwave until you can break it into clumps with your fingers. Add these clumps to the bowl and turn the mixer on to combine.

Step Two: Walk away. Seriously. The butter and brown sugar should be mixed at a fairly high speed for 10 minutes or so, so that they combine and change color and become fluffy. This is what makes the cookie so good! If you’re doing this with a hand mixer, be patient.

It should look like this when it's ready.

Step Three: Add the eggs, combine. Add the vanilla, combine. Add the dry ingredients. Recipes often say to mix them together beforehand so you don’t get pockets of salt, and I think that’s good advice, but I don’t usually do it. Haven’t had a problem so far.

Step Four: At this point you should have a lovely dough. Now I add the chocolate chips and nuts until it’s where I want it. Some people like more, some less. Keep in mind that this dough is less sweet than classic Tollhouse dough, so you might want to up your chocolate quotient.

Step Five: Preheat the oven to 350. Stick dough in the freezer for a while (30 minutes?) so it’s stiff when you drop it by large tablespoons onto the greased baking sheet. Oh yes, these are pretty big, fluffy cookies. Bake for 8-12 minutes, keeping a careful eye so the bottoms don’t burn. Let cool. Enjoy.

No wimpy cookies here.

If the cookies seem slightly undercooked at 12 minutes, take them out anyway. They’ll continue to cook as they cool, so you’ll get perfectly soft insides. These freeze pretty well, too– I like to throw a bag in the freezer in case of an emergency.



Filed under Chocolate, Dessert.

4 responses to “Dad’s Chocolate Chip Cookies

  1. Roberta

    Have to try this version. Of course I’ve been baking these cookies for 5 (yes!) decades now and the jury’s still out on the beating part. I used to try “stirring” the dough by hand, so as NOT to crush the sugar granuals. Those granuals feel oh-so-good in your mouth! Then I tried freezing the balls of dough (on the sheet) partially (learned this trick from the Fairmont pastry chefs) and SMASH the cookie down halfway through the baking process. Makes the middle chewy, they said. They also had ALL DAY to bake! Gosh there has to be a million versions. Since your Dad is my favorite favorite cuz, I’ll give this one a try. Do you think it’s on Weight Watchers, though?

    Ps. Doubling the vanilla was also one of Fairmont chef’s tricks! And it has to be really good vanilla, like Penzy’s Double Strength. I can smell it as I type…..

  2. Roberta

    Make that granules. I can’t spell early in the a.m.!

  3. suzanne

    I just made my gizzillionth batch of chocolate chip cookies and now thanks to your recipe, will make my quzzillion and one batch. My cookies never turn out the same, but the grandkids can criicize or compliment with their mouths full. The best tool for making them is the pampered chef large scoop, why waste time with the small one. The only disadvantage is that you can’t lick your fingers afer pushing the dough off with a spoon. Your sight is really great, brains, beauty and creativity, good genes. Keep up the good work, will let you know how it works out. LYM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s